"He can really defend, and he's got some power, too," Meister said. "I think he'd hit well in [Miller Park]."
Next up is Jimmy Rollins, the longtime Phillie who wants a five-year deal, according to reports. The Brewers probably would not be willing to go that far, but Melvin said Wednesday afternoon that he intended to touch base with agent Dan Lozano anyway.
The Brewers have yet to make any offers, Melvin said.
"You never know who says, 'We're willing to take a one-year deal and then test the market next year," Melvin said. "You don't know. The worst thing is, you find that someone signed a one- or two-year deal with someone else and you say, 'We should have.'"
The Brewers don't have a Minor League option to plug into shortstop the way they do at first base, where Melvin has offered growing evidence that 26-year-old longtime prospect Mat Gamel will take over for Fielder in 2012.
The most likely fit may be Betancourt, even though the Brewers have already paid $2 million to buy out a 2012 club option that would have paid $6 million. That $2 million came from the Royals as part of a December 2010 trade that sent Betancourt and right-hander Zack Greinke to Milwaukee for a package that included Alcides Escobar, who was considered the Brewers' shortstop of the future.
Melvin said he considers the $2 million expenditure part of the 2011 budget.
According to Melvin, Betancourt is "very interested" in returning, but the Brewers asked for time to scan the market. Betancourt batted .252 with 13 home runs and 68 RBIs in 2011. The only National League shortstop with more RBIs was Colorado's Troy Tulowitzki, but Betancourt finished next-to-last among all qualified NL hitters with a .271 on-base percentage.
"We do have a need because we don't have anybody signed at this point," Melvin said. "Like I said at the end of the year, I would be satisfied with having 'Yuni' back. I think he did a better job than some of the critics [argue]."
Melvin's argument centered around the fact that Betancourt played more games in 2011 than any of the free-agent shortstops (he and Atlanta's Alex Gonzalez tied with 146 starts) and that Betancourt has played in more than 150 games in five of the last six seasons.
"You have to be a good shortstop to play over 150 games," Melvin said. "If you're not that good, you're not playing that many games."