The Brewers' rally fizzled there. The teams had decided before the ninth that they would not play extra innings.
The star of the game was Davis, a Brewers Minor League left fielder who has seen significant playing time with Ryan Braun away at the World Baseball Classic. Davis has hit six homers this spring including one in an exhibition against Team Canada and with Saturday's 3-for-3 afternoon is batting .364 in official Cactus League at-bats. He could have a harder time finding at-bats after Sunday, when Braun returns to Brewers camp.
Third baseman Aramis Ramirez and center fielder Logan Schafer each collected two hits and an RBI for the Brewers, who took a 5-1 lead in the first inning, saw the Reds fight back into a 5-5 tie, then pushed ahead in the bottom of the third when Davis hit a two-run homer off Cincinnati starter Mike Leake.
Davis homered again in the fifth inning against left-hander Sean Marshall.
Leake was knocked around over 3 1/3 innings, allowing seven runs (five earned) on 10 hits.
The Reds were a split squad but sent an "A" lineup to Maryvale, featuring longtime Brewers tormentors Votto and Jay Bruce. Each had two hits against Brewers starter Mike Fiers, including a bloop two-run single for Votto and a pair of well-placed doubles for Bruce, one down each foul line. Votto added another hit in the seventh inning, an opposite-field, solo home run off left-hander Travis Webb that cut the Reds' deficit to 8-6.
Fiers surrendered five earned runs on eight hits and two walks over four innings. He struck out four, but saw his Cactus League ERA rise to 4.41.
He is not the only one of the Brewers' young pitchers to take some lumps lately. Manager Ron Roenicke said he was not concerned yet, and reiterated that the Brewers are comfortable with their internal pitching candidates.
"We saw what they are last year," Roenicke said. "We saw where we think they can be. Coming into Spring Training and worrying about these young guys -- we're still halfway through March, and I don't think that's a panic time for a young pitcher to be locked in."
Up next: Catcher Jonathan Lucroy could be back in the Brewers' starting lineup as early as Sunday, when the team travels to Glendale to play the Dodgers at Camelback Ranch. Yovani Gallardo will make a slightly abbreviated start on three days' rest to line him up for a fourth consecutive Opening Day start and might reunite with No. 1 catcher Lucroy, who returned late Saturday from a stint with Team USA in the World Baseball Classic. Game audio will air live via MLB.com webcast beginning at 3 p.m. CT, and a delayed television broadcast will air on MLB Network.
Adam McCalvy is a reporter for MLB.com. Read his blog, Brew Beat, and follow him on Twitter at @AdamMcCalvy. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.