This year, the window for renewals opened Tuesday and closes March 11, but the Brewers' policy is to renew unsigned players prior to their Cactus League opener. That means a deal with Gallardo must be struck on or before Thursday, when the Brewers face the Giants in Scottsdale, Ariz., at 2:05 p.m. CT, a game that can be heard on an exclusive brewers.com Web cast. Gallardo is scheduled to debut on Friday against the A's, which will also be aired on a brewers.com Web cast at 2:05 p.m.
The Brewers have attempted to take the subjectivity out of such negotiations by paying players ineligible for arbitration based on a system of performance- and awards-based criteria. The sticking point with Gallardo, according to Brewers assistant general manager Gord Ash, who is handling negotiations with Gallardo's agent, former Major Leaguer Bobby Witt, is that one criterion for the club's pay scale is the Elias rankings system, which takes into account a player's past two seasons. Since Gallardo missed most of 2008 with right knee injuries, he loses points and is compensated slightly less than some Brewers who have gone through the system before him.
"To this point, we've agreed to disagree," Ash said.
Reached by telephone, Witt said the process was "probably" heading toward a renewal.
"The Brewers have a system in place to compensate their players, and where they have Yovani and what Yovani thinks, there is a difference there," Witt said. "Whatever happens, by no means is Yovani going to be upset. He's going to prepare for the season like he always does. If it does happen, it wouldn't be the first time and it won't be the last."
Gallardo was the Brewers' final player in line for a renewal last season before agreeing to terms on a contract reportedly worth $414,000. Gallardo went on to post a 13-12 record in 2009 with a 3.73 ERA and 204 strikeouts. He ranked fifth in the National League in whiffs, and third with a .219 batting average against.
To this point, according to both Ash and Brewers general manager Doug Melvin, the sides have only spoken about a one-year contract for 2010. The Brewers have had limited talks with Witt in the past about a multiyear deal for Gallardo but couldn't find common ground.
Gallardo is on track to be arbitration-eligible following the 2010 season and would be one of the Brewers' key cases. Fellow starter Manny Parra projects as a first-time eligible player, and Fielder, Hart and second baseman Rickie Weeks will be eligible for the final time before hitting the free-agent market following the 2011 season.
Gallardo is the leading candidate to start the Brewers' April 5 season opener against the Rockies, though manager Ken Macha has not made official his plans.